Why Doesn’t Construction Learn From Its Mistakes? It Needs a Black Box
Construction repeats its mistakes because they’re hidden, not because it can’t learn. Avoidable error costs about 5% of project cost directly, and 10 to 25% once the knock-on costs are counted (Get It Right Initiative). Aviation fixed this with a black box: record everything, blame no one, and share what works. Construction can do the same.
Last reviewed: November 2026
I’ve just re-read Matthew Syed’s Black Box Thinking, one of my favourite books. Ten years after I first read it, I still can’t find a contractor that has made the move it describes.
Construction talks endlessly about learning culture, continuous improvement and collaboration, yet the same failures turn up on job after job. Why? Because the industry still can’t do the one thing that drives improvement: tell the truth about what’s going wrong.
What is black box thinking?
It’s the idea at the heart of Syed’s book (Black Box Thinking, John Murray, 2015): progress comes from treating failure as information, not as something to hide. Aviation is his model.
Every commercial aircraft carries flight recorders, and every serious incident is investigated to find causes, not culprits. In the UK, aviation has run a mandatory occurrence reporting scheme since 1976. Its stated purpose “is not to attribute blame or liability but supports continued learning to make flying safer” (UK Civil Aviation Authority). Reports have doubled, from 31,908 in 2019 to 62,215 in 2025 (CAA data). In a reporting culture, more reports is a sign of health, not danger.
The result is an industry where accidents are rare: 1.32 accidents per million flight sectors worldwide in 2025 (IATA Safety Report 2025).
Why does construction keep making the same mistakes?
We don’t have a learning problem. We have an honesty problem.
Most lessons-learned processes in construction are theatre, and everyone knows it. They’re:
- written at the end, when everyone’s exhausted;
- sanitised, so nobody is upset;
- filed where nobody will read them;
- repeated on the next job anyway.
That isn’t learning. It’s reputation management, and the industry has become world-class at it.
The cost is not small. The Get It Right Initiative puts the direct cost of avoidable error at around 5% of project cost, and the full cost at 10 to 25% once indirect and knock-on costs are counted (GIRI, 2015). On a 3% margin, error alone costs more than the profit. More in what building errors cost.
What does construction already have?
More than people think, but none of it reaches the everyday mistakes that eat margin.
- RIDDOR requires employers to report deaths, specified injuries, injuries that keep someone off work for more than 7 days, certain diseases and listed dangerous occurrences (HSE, RIDDOR). It records harm after it happens. In 2024/25, 35 construction workers were killed (HSE, Construction statistics 2025). HSE consulted in 2026 on adding new dangerous occurrences, including temporary works and trench collapses.
- CROSS-UK is the confidential reporting scheme for structural and fire safety, run by the Institution of Civil Engineers and the Institution of Structural Engineers. All reports are anonymised, and it has published more than 1,000 safety reports in twenty years (IStructE). In 2025 it was named the official voluntary reporting system for structural and fire safety until at least 2028 (IStructE).
- The Get It Right Initiative works with members to measure error. One contractor that captured its error data found 2.28% of project costs attributable to error, a figure it treated as preliminary (GIRI case study).
- Lessons-learned registers inside most contractors.
These are good schemes. But RIDDOR and CROSS deal with safety, not with the late drawing, the missed interface or the clash that costs a week. And no UK main contractor I know of publishes what it learns.
Aviation against construction
Aviation against construction: what is recorded, who reviews it, whether it is shared, and what changes as a result.
Why doesn’t any contractor publish its learning data?
Because doing so would expose the truth: construction is terrified of transparency. Terrified of blame, of litigation, of losing bids, and of admitting the same issues keep happening.
But here’s the uncomfortable bit: the businesses that hide the most are usually the ones repeating the same failures. If you’re confident in your culture, your systems and your controls, you don’t fear transparency. You welcome it.
And the culture that hides learning is the same culture that says “don’t escalate that yet”, “keep that internal” and “let’s not put that in writing”. That behaviour kills learning. It kills progress. Sometimes it kills people.
What would a construction black box look like?
Not radical. Responsible. In practice, five things:
- Record everything, without blame. Every missed task, near miss, defect and design gap, captured at source by the people who saw it, and never rewritten on its way up.
- Look for patterns across jobs, not culprits on one. The value is in the cause that shows up on ten sites, not the person on one.
- Respond fast and visibly. If people report a problem and nothing happens, they stop reporting. The daily version of this is the Live Loop.
- Protect the reporter. Like the aviation scheme, the record is for learning, not for discipline or claims.
- Share the solution, not the mistake. Sharing a mistake invites blame. Sharing a solution invites adoption. It’s the same learning, pointed the opposite way.
That last point is where I’ve changed my own mind. I used to think the first contractor brave enough to publish its mistakes would redefine the industry. I now think the bigger win is publishing what works: the fix, the method, the better way, out in the open where the next team can find it. That’s why I wrote Going for Gold, twenty-two years of delivery, failures included, written down for anyone to use. The book calls it leaving the recorder on.
The black box is step 5 of the 2026 productivity playbook, and it only works in a culture where bad news is safe. That’s the first of the 5 culture problems hiding in plain sight.
Who’s brave enough?
Construction won’t change until someone stops playing safe and starts playing honest. Imagine a contractor that records every failure without blame, finds its patterns across every job, and publishes its solutions for the whole industry to use. It would win clients’ trust, attract better people and improve faster than anyone else.
The bottom line: the question isn’t whether construction can learn from its mistakes. It’s which business will be brave enough to leave the recorder on first, and which will be left behind when it does.
FAQs
What is black box thinking?
The idea, from Matthew Syed’s 2015 book, that progress comes from treating failure as information: record it, investigate causes not culprits, and share what you learn. Aviation is the model.
How can construction companies learn from mistakes?
Record every failure at source without blame, look for patterns across jobs, respond quickly and visibly, and share the solutions that work.
What is CROSS in construction?
CROSS-UK is the confidential, anonymised reporting scheme for structural and fire safety, run by the ICE and IStructE. It publishes safety reports so the industry can learn without blame.
Why do construction projects repeat the same errors?
Because lessons are hidden, sanitised or filed away rather than shared, so the causes are never fixed. Avoidable error costs 10 to 25% of project cost once all the knock-on costs are counted (GIRI).
Sources
- Syed, M., Black Box Thinking, John Murray, 2015.
- UK Civil Aviation Authority, Mandatory Occurrence Reporting scheme and data (31,908 reports in 2019; 62,215 in 2025).
- IATA, Safety Report 2025, 9 March 2026 (1.32 accidents per million sectors).
- Get It Right Initiative, research report, November 2015 (about 5% direct; 10 to 25% total), as on /what-building-errors-cost/. GIRI Brymor case study, May 2022.
- HSE, RIDDOR; HSE Construction statistics in Great Britain, 2025 (35 deaths in 2024/25).
- IStructE, CROSS-UK pages, including the 9 July 2025 announcement.
- “Share the solution, not the mistake” and “leave the recorder on” are from the author’s book, Going for Gold (afterword).
Andy Pritchard MCIOB
CIOB Gold Medal, Construction Manager of the Year 2019. Founder of Constructing Culture and author of Going for Gold. About Andy →