Why Do Subcontractors Charge Some Contractors More?

Short answer

Yes. Many trade partners keep two or three prices and choose one by contractor. The best prices go to contractors whose jobs finish on time, who pay promptly and who can show the next job. Repeat relationships only bring prices down when four conditions hold: a credible pipeline, two or three partners per trade, prompt payment and a hard measure of delivery.

By Andy Pritchard MCIOB. Last reviewed: November 2026.

A note on words. Most people search for “subcontractor”, so that is the word in our headings. In the text we say “trade partner”, because that is how the contractors who get the best prices treat them.

Here is a question I put to procurement teams. If the same trade partner works for you and for your competitor down the road, why are they brilliant for them and only adequate for you?

This long read is the deeper version of my LinkedIn article on the same question. It sets out the evidence from construction, car manufacturing and three other countries, and what it means for a UK contractor in 2026.

Do subcontractors charge some contractors more?

Yes. Many trade partners keep two or three prices and choose one by contractor, and they will tell you so if you ask the right way.

Andy Pritchard’s two-price finding (2026)

Over a 23-year career in UK construction, scores of trade partners have told Andy Pritchard MCIOB, off the record, that they keep two or three prices and choose one by contractor. A dozen said so in the two months to November 2026 alone. The best price goes to the contractor whose jobs finish on time, not to the softest one.

Basis: first-hand conversations, not a survey. No partner is named.

Over my career, scores of partners have told me off the record that they keep two or three different prices, depending on which contractor they’re pricing for. A dozen have said it to me in the last two months alone.

In my book, Going for Gold, I wrote that every good partner keeps a mental league table of its clients. The contractors who pay on time, plan properly, communicate like adults and stand by them when things go wrong get the best teams, the keenest prices and the fastest response. Everyone else gets what’s left.

The best price doesn’t go to the soft contractor. Some partners look for the brilliant project managers who’ll run them hard and expect the world. They know that job will finish on time, everything will be ready when they arrive, and they’ll make some money.

The contractors who are aggressive and come after them for costs get a different price. So do the ones whose project managers, or whose operations, aren’t very good. The partner knows that job will run late and their prelims will grow, so they price the risk in.

I don’t know a partner who won’t admit, off the record, to different rates for different contractors.

What do subcontractors look for in a main contractor?

The same seven things, whatever the trade. The contractors who get them right get a partner’s best teams, keenest prices and fastest response.

  1. Pays on time, every time.
  2. Plans properly, with a programme the partner can trust.
  3. Has the area ready when the partner arrives.
  4. Communicates like an adult: early, honest, no surprises.
  5. Stands by them when things go wrong.
  6. Shows them the next job.
  7. Is fair when costs rise, and agrees an increase rather than holding a rate that loses them money.

Get these right and you move up their league table. Get them wrong and the risk is priced into your next quote.

Why does the same subcontractor perform better for your competitor?

Because your competitor is the better customer to that partner. Partners put their best people, fastest response and keenest prices where the job runs well and the next job is likely.

I learned the answer from the other side of it.

When I recovered two of my projects, a huge share of the extra pace came from labour: first M&E, then drylining. On one of them, the labour on site doubled at a day’s notice.

Those dozens of extra builders didn’t come from nowhere. They came off other contractors’ jobs. Contractors who mattered less to those partners than we did. Contractors without a supply chain strategy.

Same firms. Same directors. Often the same operatives. The difference was the customer.

Car manufacturing tested this thirty years ago, and kept the data. In the early 1990s, several big suppliers sold the same kinds of parts to a Japanese carmaker and to American carmakers. Between 1990 and 1996, those same suppliers cut their defects by 50 percent for the Japanese customer and by 26 percent for their biggest American customer.

SAME SUPPLIERS, TWO CUSTOMERS How much the same suppliers cut their defects, 1990 to 1996 50% For the Japanese customer 26% For their biggest American customer Source: Dyer and Hatch (2006), cited in Helper and Henderson (2014), Journal of Economic Perspectives.
Same suppliers, same factories, twice the improvement for one customer. Source: Dyer and Hatch (2006), cited in Helper and Henderson (2014).

What does distrust cost a contractor?

Real money. In the car industry, the least trusted buyer paid five times as much to manage its suppliers as the most trusted one.

I once launched a new supply chain strategy at a business whose partners had learned to expect the worst. I sat in a room with ten of its key partners and told them that, from now on, the relationship would be built on trust.

That’s an easy thing to say from the main contractor’s side of the table. For the partners it was a giant leap of faith. They had seen the opposite behaviour from that business for years before I arrived.

What earned their trust wasn’t the meeting. It was following through on our promises, on every project.

Distrust has a price. A study of 344 relationships between carmakers and their suppliers found the least trusted carmaker had five times the procurement costs of the most trusted one (Dyer and Chu, 2003). Every clause, every check, every argument over a price has to be paid for by somebody.

When do repeat subcontractor relationships actually lower prices?

Only when four conditions hold: a credible pipeline of work, two or three partners per trade, prompt payment and a hard measure of delivery. The evidence from the UK, the USA, Australia and the car industry points to the same four. Miss one and the relationship stops paying.

1. A credible pipelineThe partner can see the next job.
2. Two or three per tradeLoyalty, with a real alternative.
3. Prompt paymentCash is the first test of trust.
4. A hard measure of deliveryEveryone sees the same numbers.

1. A credible pipeline of future work

On Californian highway contracts, repeat pairings of main contractor and trade partner produced more bids and lower bids, but only where more work was expected. Where little future work was in prospect, the effect disappeared (Gil and Marion, 2013). The pipeline is what makes the relationship pay.

For a UK contractor, that means telling your key partners what is coming: the regional programme, the likely start dates, the packages they could win. A partner who can plan its labour around your next six months will price your next job very differently from one who can’t.

2. Two or three partners per trade, never one

The Japanese carmakers were not soft. Toyota and Honda typically develop two or three suppliers for each part. They sent monthly report cards, set hard cost-down targets and expected them to be met. They sent their own engineers into supplier factories to help find the savings, and shared the savings (Liker and Choi, 2004).

UK government reached the same conclusion for construction. The National Audit Office recommended keeping competitive tension inside partnering, for example two tiers of suppliers in each area (NAO, 2005). Loyalty works when exit stays real.

3. Prompt payment

Payment record sits near the top of partners’ reasons to bid. That is my experience, and the surveys point the same way. In an April 2026 survey of 754 Australian trade firms by Payapps, a payment software company, 77 percent said a contractor’s payment reputation affected whether or how they bid. There is no comparable UK survey.

UK payment is improving at the top of the chain. Build UK’s tier one members report average payment times down from 45 days in 2018 to 29 days, and its first retentions benchmark found 74 percent of client retentions were passed down to the supply chain (Build UK, August 2026). Those are self-reported invoice-to-payment figures. They say nothing about valuations cut or certificates delayed, which is where most partner complaints sit.

The law is moving too. The Commercial Payments Bill would cap the time between a payment falling due and the final date for payment at 60 days in private construction contracts, and 30 days with public bodies. It cleared the Lords on 20 October 2026 and is now before the Commons as Bill 166. If you are relying on the cap, check where the Bill stands; it is not yet law.

The contrast between two anchor customers says it all. After the 2025 cyber attack, JLR restarted production with a scheme paying production-critical suppliers early, at its own financing cost. Carillion, Parliament found, imposed 120-day terms on its suppliers and used an early payment facility to prop up its business model. The anchor customer in automotive funded its suppliers. The anchor customer in construction financed itself from them.

4. A hard measure of delivery

I’ve used the same combination of demanding and supportive in construction. At more than one contractor, part of the strategy I put in place changed how success was measured, from commercial results to operational performance. That went down to the daily tasks of every builder, across the country, tracked as PPC: the share of the tasks committed to each week that were actually finished.

When you first switch it on, the numbers are brutal. Glenn Ballard’s Last Planner research found that typically only about half the work planned for a week gets done. Buildots’ 2026 benchmarks, drawn from more than 250 projects, found the typical project delivers 63 percent of its scheduled weekly output. That isn’t a bad week. It’s how the industry already runs, and now you can see it.

That’s the moment that needs trust and high standards together. Show your surveyors and commercial teams that much failure and the instinct is to get defensive and go after the supply chain. If they do, the partners stop telling you the truth and the number stops meaning anything.

It took six months to a year of retraining to lift PPC to 70 percent, and on the best sites to 80 percent. Even then, one task in five still fails, every week. But at 80 percent you are among the best.

PPC: THE SHARE OF EACH WEEK’S COMMITMENTS FINISHED Brutal when you switch it on. Among the best at 80%. 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 0 3 6 9 12 Months after switching on PPC Average: 63% Average: about half Switch-on Top sites: 80% Top performing sites: Andy Pritchard’s experience across several contractors, illustrative, not measured data. Averages: Ballard, Last Planner research (2000); Buildots 2026 benchmarks (work installed, not PPC).
Top performing sites: Andy Pritchard’s experience across several contractors, illustrative, not measured data. Averages: Ballard (2000); Buildots 2026 benchmarks (work installed, not PPC).

Does a long-term supply chain lower costs on its own?

No. Long relationships improve quality, but the cost gains only come from improving the work together and keeping a real alternative.

In a study of 1,147 car parts suppliers in the USA and Japan, simply working with the same supplier for a long time bought better quality, but no cost advantage. The cost gains only came where the customer and supplier worked on improvement together, deliberately, year after year (Helper and Sako, 1995).

That matches what we see in our industry. UK contractors already win most of their turnover from repeat clients (a median of 79 percent, Constructing Excellence, 2012), yet cost predictability has stayed poor. Doing business again is not the same as managing a supply chain on purpose.

Australia ran the experiment at scale. After 15 years of public sector alliancing, Victoria’s Department of Treasury and Finance found alliances delivered on time, without disputes and with earlier starts. But their cost grew about 50 percent from business case to outturn, against about 20 percent for traditional contracts, and most of that growth came before the target price was fixed (DTF Victoria, 2009). Collaboration fixed time and relationships. It did not fix cost on its own.

The counterweight is churn. Across the whole supply chain, I’d always build in at least 5 percent a year, and I recommend about 10 percent. New, brilliant businesses are set up all the time, and some will be more efficient and deliver better than the partners you already have.

Do it on your projects too, but don’t put all the churn on one job. The ideal is a project full of repeat, trusted partners, plus one new one being tried.

What happens when a contractor squeezes its subcontractors?

It wins in year one and loses afterwards. Quality slips, the best partners work elsewhere or go bust, and the saving comes back as cost.

One American manufacturer took billions out of its suppliers through blanket price cuts in the early 1990s. It worked in year one. Then quality slipped and launches were delayed. In the industry’s 2025 supplier survey, suppliers felt like a true partner twelve times more often with the top three carmakers than with the bottom three (Plante Moran, 2025).

The year-one saving was real. So was the cost that followed.

Construction ran the same experiment after Covid, when inflation went past 10 percent. It wasn’t one company; it was the whole industry. Frameworks and agreed rates were everywhere, and suddenly they were losing partners serious money.

It comes down to a simple fact. Hold your supply chain to a rate that makes them lose dramatic amounts of money, and there’s a strong chance they go bust. If they go bust, you lose far more than you would have by being fair and agreeing the increase.

Chasing the perfect win, where one side gets everything and the other gets nothing, is incredibly short-sighted. Everybody should share in the profits and, when it goes wrong, share in the losses. The outcome everybody actually wants is for everybody to survive.

The risk is live in 2026. Specialist trades are still the bulk of construction insolvencies: 2,208 of the 3,931 construction firms that became insolvent in England and Wales in 2025 (Insolvency Service). Building costs are rising faster than tender prices, 3.8 percent a year against 3.2 percent (BCIS, June 2026). Partners are getting choosier about who they work for and how much credit they give. Your position in their league table is turning into a commercial fact.

The better customer against the customer who squeezes

On…The better customerThe customer who squeezes
Partners per tradeTwo or three, chosen in advanceWhoever is cheapest this time
Future workShows the pipelinePromises nothing beyond this job
TargetsHard targets, and help to hit themBlanket price cuts
PaymentPrompt and predictableLong terms, cut valuations
MeasurementShares the same numbers every weekUses the numbers to argue
InflationAgrees a fair increaseHolds the rate until the partner fails
What it getsThe best teams, keenest prices and fastest responseWhat’s left, with the risk priced in

How do you measure which subcontractors to buy from next?

Measure PPC by trade partner every week, with the reason for every missed commitment, alongside tender to final account.

Most contractors judge a trade partner on the tender and the final account. Both tell you what happened after it is too late to change it.

The leading measure is PPC by trade partner, every week, with the reason for every missed commitment logged against the partner, package or decision that caused it. The lagging measure is tender to final account. Together they let site performance decide who you buy from next, not the tender sheet.

One rule keeps it fair. The record must separate the delay a partner controls from the delay it does not: other trades, design and the client. Otherwise the data punishes the wrong people, and you lose the honesty that made it worth collecting. Share the trends with each partner and talk them through. Don’t publish a league table.

How to be the customer subcontractors want to perform for

So the answer isn’t to be nice to your supply chain. It’s to be the customer they want to perform for.

  • Keep a small group per key trade. Two or three, chosen in advance, not one and not twenty.
  • Show them their own numbers. Programme, quality, safety, commercial. Regularly, honestly, and tied to future work.
  • Set hard targets and help them hit them. Bring them in early enough to improve the job, not just price it.
  • Pay like you mean it. Payment record sits near the top of partners’ reasons to bid.
  • Let them see the next job. The pipeline is what makes the relationship pay.

Demanding and loyal at the same time. That’s the combination the best buyers in the world use. It is also what we build into our supply chain frameworks work, and what I wrote about in building a supply chain that wants to work with you.

Do it Monday. Pick one partner who works for you and for a competitor. Ask them, in person: what does the other contractor do that we don’t? Then listen. Don’t defend. If they’re honest, it’ll be the cheapest consultancy you ever get.

The bottom line: your trade partners already have a price for you. It reflects how you plan, how you pay and whether they can see the next job. Change those, and the price changes with them.

Related reading: what building errors cost, why scaling, not winning work, is the problem and the UK retentions ban.

Frequently asked questions

Do subcontractors really charge different contractors different prices?

Yes. In my experience many trade partners keep two or three prices and choose one by contractor. The best prices go to contractors whose jobs finish on time, are ready when the partner arrives and let the partner make money. Contractors who are aggressive on costs, or whose jobs run late, get a price with the risk priced in.

What do subcontractors look for in a main contractor?

Seven things: paying on time, planning properly, having the area ready when they arrive, communicating early and honestly, standing by them when things go wrong, showing them the next job, and being fair when costs rise.

How can a contractor get better prices from subcontractors?

Keep two or three partners per key trade, show them the pipeline of future work, pay promptly, set hard targets and help partners hit them, and measure delivery with the same numbers every week. Repeat relationships only lower prices when those conditions hold.

Does using the same subcontractors on every job save money?

Not on its own. Long relationships improve quality, but the cost gains come from working on improvement together and keeping a credible alternative. Contractors already win most of their work from repeat clients without becoming more cost-predictable.

What is PPC in construction?

PPC, or Percent Plan Complete, is the share of the tasks committed to each week that are actually finished. Typical sites start at about half. The best sites reach about 80 percent after six months to a year of practice.

Is the Commercial Payments Bill law yet?

No. It cleared the House of Lords on 20 October 2026 and is now before the House of Commons as Bill 166. As drafted it would cap the time between a payment falling due and the final date for payment at 60 days in private construction contracts, and 30 days with public bodies.

Sources

  • Dyer, J. and Hatch, N. (2006), cited in Helper, S. and Henderson, R. (2014), “Management Practices, Relational Contracts, and the Decline of General Motors”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 28(1).
  • Dyer, J. and Chu, W. (2003), “The Role of Trustworthiness in Reducing Transaction Costs”, Organization Science, 14(1). 344 supplier relationships.
  • Liker, J. and Choi, T. (2004), “Building Deep Supplier Relationships”, Harvard Business Review, December.
  • Helper, S. and Sako, M. (1995), survey of 1,147 suppliers in the USA and Japan, Sloan Management Review.
  • Gil, R. and Marion, J. (2013), “Self-Enforcing Agreements and Relational Contracting: Evidence from California Highway Procurement”, Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, 29(2).
  • National Audit Office (2005), Improving Public Services through Better Construction.
  • Department of Treasury and Finance, Victoria (2009), In Pursuit of Additional Value: A benchmarking study into alliancing in the Australian public sector.
  • Plante Moran, Working Relations Index, May 2025.
  • Ballard, G. (2000), The Last Planner System of Production Control, PhD thesis, University of Birmingham.
  • Buildots 2026 benchmarks, as reported by Construction Management, October 2026.
  • Constructing Excellence (2012), UK industry KPIs: median 79 percent of turnover from repeat clients.
  • Payapps (13 April 2026), survey of 754 Australian trade firms (vendor research).
  • Build UK, payment and retentions benchmarks, reported by The Construction Index, 5 August 2026.
  • Commercial Payments Bill, Commons Bill 166; Lords third reading 20 October 2026 (UK Parliament). Stage checked on publication.
  • JLR supplier early payment scheme after the 2025 cyber attack, reported by AM Online, October 2025.
  • House of Commons Business and Work and Pensions committees, Carillion report (2018), via Construction Management, 14 May 2018.
  • Insolvency Service, 2025 annual figures for England and Wales: 3,931 construction insolvencies, 2,208 in specialised construction activities.
  • BCIS five-year forecast, June 2026: building costs up 3.8 percent a year, tender prices up 3.2 percent.
  • ONS, CPI annual inflation peaked at 11.1 percent in October 2022.
Andy Pritchard MCIOB, founder of Constructing Culture

Andy Pritchard MCIOB

CIOB Gold Medal, Construction Manager of the Year 2019. Founder of Constructing Culture and author of Going for Gold. About Andy →