What Do Retentions Cost Your Supply Chain Relationships?

Short answer

Cash retentions cost main contractors more than the 5% they hold. Trade partners price them into tenders, chase them for months, and save their best teams for clients who pay in full. The Commercial Payments Bill would void new retention clauses after a 2-year transition and force any retention still held to be paid back 3 years after it starts. Contractors who replace retentions with quality control and fair payment now will win the best partners first.

Last reviewed: November 2026

The UK retentions ban debate has been running for years. The arguments for and against are well-rehearsed: defect security for contractors on one side, cash flow for trade partners on the other. But what gets lost in the policy discussion is something more fundamental: what retentions actually do to the relationship between main contractors and their supply chain.

Because retentions aren’t just a financial mechanism. They’re a signal. They tell your trade partners exactly what you think of them: that you don’t trust them enough to pay in full for the work they’ve done. And that signal shapes every interaction that follows, from how they price your work to how they prioritise your projects when things get busy.

The UK retentions ban, proposed in the Commercial Payments Bill, is not expected to come into force before 2027, but the smart contractors aren’t waiting. They’re already rethinking how they build trust with their supply chain, and finding that the commercial benefits go far beyond what retentions ever protected.

What do retentions really cost a main contractor?

The standard argument for retentions is simple: they protect the client and main contractor against defects. Hold back a percentage, release it after the defects period, everyone’s covered.

In practice, the cost of retentions is much higher than the percentage held. Trade partners price retentions into their tenders. They know they’re funding your cash flow for twelve months or more, and they account for that. Some add a straight percentage. Others just reduce the effort they put into competitive pricing because they know the margin will be eroded anyway.

Then there’s the operational cost. Chasing retentions release takes time and resource on both sides. Disputes over defects liability become leverage games. Trade partners who feel they’ve been treated unfairly on one project think twice before giving you their best team on the next one.

What a 5% retention really costs
CostWho carries it firstHow it comes back to you
Cash held for 12 months or moreTrade partnerAdded to the tender price
Chasing releaseBoth sidesCommercial time on every closed job
Defects used as leverageTrade partnerDisputes, and partners who stop flagging problems
Treated as untrustedTrade partnerTheir best team goes to someone else

The UK retentions ban is forcing businesses to confront a truth that was always there: retentions cost more in damaged relationships and inflated prices than they ever save in defect remediation.

Looking for the law itself: what the Bill says, the dates, and what replaces the 5%? Read our full guide: The UK retentions ban, explained for contractors.

Why does trust beat contractual leverage?

The best supply chain relationships in construction are built on trust, not contractual leverage. Trade partners who trust their main contractor deliver better work, flag problems earlier, price more competitively, and commit their best people to your projects.

When your supply chain believes they’ll be treated fairly, the commercial benefits compound across every project.

The UK retentions ban will level the playing field eventually. But the contractors who move first get the advantage now: they become the client of choice for the best trade partners in their market. And in a sector with a skills shortage at every level, being the contractor people want to work with is worth more than any retention fund.

How do you protect quality without a retention?

The concern most MDs raise about the UK retentions ban is legitimate: what happens when there are genuine defects and the trade partner has been paid in full?

The answer is that retentions were never a good defect management tool in the first place. They’re a blunt financial hold, not a quality assurance mechanism. Businesses that rely on retentions to manage quality are using yesterday’s approach to a problem that has better solutions available.

Effective defect management comes from quality systems that work during construction, not financial penalties applied after it. Collaborative snagging processes, joint inspections, clear completion criteria agreed before work starts: these all deliver better quality outcomes than holding someone’s money for a year.

What security clients can ask for instead is still being settled. The Government says it will work with surety providers so that products are available, and escrow used only as a way of paying stays allowed. But money a third party holds back against your performance could still count as a retention. Take advice on your own contracts, and see our full guide to the ban for where it stands.

What does your retention policy say about your culture?

How you treat your supply chain is a direct reflection of your company culture. Businesses that default to contractual leverage, adversarial negotiations, and punitive payment terms create a culture of distrust that flows through everything they do.

That culture doesn’t stay in the commercial department. It shows up on site in how trade partners engage with your team. It shows up in how problems get reported, or hidden. It shows up in the quality of work delivered when nobody’s checking.

The UK retentions ban is one piece of a larger shift happening in the industry. The businesses that treat it as just a compliance issue will change the minimum. The ones that treat it as an opportunity to rebuild how they work with their supply chain will see the benefits across every project, every relationship, and every tender.

What should contractors do before the ban?

  1. Count it. Add up retention you hold and retention you owe, and release what is already due.
  2. Move quality forward. Hold points, joint inspections and completion criteria agreed before work starts, so defects are caught while the partner is still on site.
  3. Agree the snagging process at pre-start, not at handover.
  4. Tell your partners what you will do in place of retention, before the law makes you.
  5. Check your contracts and bonds with your lawyers once the Bill’s final wording is known.

At Constructing Culture, we work with contractors to build the kind of supply chain relationships that deliver better projects. That means looking at payment practices, contractual culture, communication, and the leadership behaviours that set the tone for how your business treats the people it works with.

The retentions ban is coming. But the businesses that will benefit most are the ones that don’t wait for legislation to start treating their supply chain as partners rather than risks. If you want to get ahead of this, let’s talk about what that looks like for your business.

The bottom line: the law will take the 5% away. Only you can decide whether your partners trust you without it.

Questions people ask

Are cash retentions being banned in UK construction?

Yes. Under the Commercial Payments Bill, introduced in May 2026, new retention clauses would be void after a 2-year transition, and any retention still held would have to be paid back by the “last retention day”, 3 years after the rules come into force. It is not yet law: the Lords finished with it on 20 October 2026 and it now goes to the Commons. Our full guide to the ban tracks where it stands.

How do retentions affect supply chain relationships?

Trade partners price retentions into their tenders and spend time chasing release, and many save their best teams and prices for contractors who pay in full.

What should main contractors do before the retentions ban?

Count the retention you hold and owe, move quality checks into the build, agree snagging early, and tell your partners what replaces retention.

Will retention bonds still be allowed?

Not yet settled. The Government says it will work with surety providers so that products are available, but how the final Act treats retention bonds is still open. Take legal advice on your own contracts.

Sources

Andy Pritchard MCIOB, founder of Constructing Culture

Andy Pritchard MCIOB

CIOB Gold Medal, Construction Manager of the Year 2019. Founder of Constructing Culture and author of Going for Gold. About Andy →